In Montreal, I’m in the middle of a revolution

Long after the protests have subsided for the evening I can hear the half-hearted clanging of pots and pans up and down Berri. 8 PM every night, without fail since Bill 78 was announced, Montreal Casserole begins. Cazerolazo, an act from Chile where people literally beat casserole dishes to create ruckus.

I watch from the 11th floor balcony, very aware of my foreignness. Trash cans, pots, pans. Stand on your street corner, or your balcony, and proclaim your dedication.

This is no longer about the students.

I made the temporary move to Montreal for the “big city” living, the glories of the anonymity factor, and the chance to challenge myself in a new setting.

I also came here in the middle of a revolution.

This past week marked 100 days of student protests over tuition fee hikes, an increase of 75% over five years. Their consistency has been astounding. Every day and night they march through the streets of Montreal in what sounds more like a parade than a protest.

It’s no longer just about tuition fee hikes. Since the protests started, Quebec has been rolling out a slew of new laws, some of them absurd. And then Bill 78 came along over a week ago, which “suspends the winter semester for striking students, and imposes strict limits on their protests, with restrictions guiding location, timing, and organization.”

Walking around with a group of nine or more people? Yes, you can get arrested for that.

Quebec reminds me of Newfoundland with its intense notions of patriotism and independence. But here I am very much an outsider, and I understand very little about what this protest stands for.

What I do know, however, is that most of Canada has a very, very skewed opinion about what’s going on here. Tip: Turn off CBC and watch CUTV Montreal. I’ve tried hard to remain neutral, but even when I allude to the protests on Facebook, I get an absurd range of responses. Most of them include something of the “these spoiled bastards should go home and work hard like everyone else” variety.

My mind is blown. This is the reaction to one of Canada’s biggest protests in history? A movement that has caught world headlines?

I’ve heard other variations. “They already have the lowest tuition in Canada, who cares if it increases by $200?” Here’s the thing, though: Quebec has the lowest tuition rates because they fucking fought for it. Get it? This has happened before. They fought for their rights, and they won. That’s how shit works. You fight for it. No matter what the cause is, you put passionate people behind it, and you see results.

Canada, are you listening?

And now, with trade unions outside of Quebec supporting the activists, things are heating up. More than $36k has been used to help out the largest student federations, and soon Ontario students will march, too.

Why aren’t we all fighting? Sure, things have to change with a rising standard of living, but why are we letting this cycle of debt continue? Student loan debt in the US alone exceeds over one trillion dollars. Things aren’t quite so bad here yet, but who says they won’t be?

Things came to a head last weekend with students lighting massive fires in the downtown core along St. Denis, while police made arrests and went into bars pepper spraying people fleeing the scene.

Let me be clear: I don’t support this behaviour from the protestors. Same goes for those disrupting classes and harassing students. You’re a stain on a perfectly good message, and you stand for nothing that the rest of the movement stands for.

There are generalizations on both sides: not all police are bad, and neither are all the students. I’ve never been anti-authority. I’ve known many amazing police officers. We need them. Don’t deny that we don’t.

But I am so inspired by these protests. I am so inspired by the fact that our youth has encouraged even the elderly to get involved, by proclaiming that freedom of speech is OURS, and so is a right to an education.

Because it is.

I’ve been caught in these protests several times, including on the way home from the gym during the “100 days” anniversary.

It was peaceful. Three times the population of St. John’s marched, and it was peaceful. I sat on a giant cement block hoping to cross the street before the thundercloud burst, but remained seated for an hour. I couldn’t tear my eyes away from the demonstration.

This movement – the wearing of red felt squares and the waving of giant flags – is a message. No matter how big or small the issue, WE have the right to refute. WE have the ability to turn things around.

And that’s my completely neutral, non-committal opinion on the matter.

PS Montreal fucking rocks.

  • May 26 2012

    Word. Fight for your future, people.

    • June 05 2012

      Gotta fight for your right to parrrrtay.

      Couldn’t help it.

  • May 26 2012
    Steven Richardson

    I was there last weekend, Candice. Saw protests in both Québec City and Montreal. Like you said, they’re mostly peaceful protests. One group walked by us in Québec City one night, and a couple of students actually came over and talked to us. They talked to us about why they were protesting, and what it meant to them. Bill 78 is a horrible thing that was passed. To the government, it’s more than just tuition hikes. They don’t want to lose their sense of control.

    • June 04 2012

      I’m so glad the students did so! I need to interview a few good ones. Happy you got the lo-down.

  • May 26 2012
    Alison

    Thanks Candice, I feel like I just got the first unbiased, on the ground report of the protests. Have fun in Montreal!

  • May 26 2012

    please keep being a good journalist. the world needs you.

    • June 04 2012

      Best comment on my blog to date. :) Thanks, Margo.

  • May 26 2012

    On a recent visit to Montreal I also got caught in the middle of the protests and the thing that amazed me was the collective consciousness of the group, the feeling of being a part of something that is so much bigger than you is unbelievable. I fully support peaceful demonstration and agree that we all have a right to change that with which we don’t agree, even if it means taking on the government.

    • June 04 2012

      Totally! Thanks for weighing in, Abby. I’ve never once felt threatened by everything going on here. It’s been incredible to watch.

  • May 26 2012

    God, I wish I lived in Montreal. Thank you for this. As a young Ontarian I hear the “they don’t even pay that high tuition!” argument so often. I can’t stand it. First off, if that pisses you off so much, why don’t you protest for lower tuition? Secondly, if no one is allowed to protest just because someone has it “worse off” than them….well, very few people in Canada at least would be able to complain about anything.

    And besides, this is obviously not just about a couple hundred dollars. There is something deeply wrong in our culture that is making young people feel they need to make some noise, that the only way they can express their frustration and have their voices heard is through clanging pots and pans and walking the streets. Keep making it, I say. Even if you don’t agree with their specific cause, the peaceful protesters are letting the powers that be know that they demand to be listened to. You can’t ignore our generation anymore. That’s powerful.

    • June 04 2012

      “There is something deeply wrong in our culture that is making young people feel they need to make some noise, that the only way they can express their frustration and have their voices heard is through clanging pots and pans and walking the streets.”

      Yes! Good god I am so glad there are still some open-minded people left in the world.

  • May 26 2012

    Well Said Candice!

    I did my undergrad at Concordia University in Montreal. I took part in several student rallies. I was always impressed be the spirit of collective involvement in Quebec. The Rest Of Canada needs to follow!

    Dave :)

    • June 04 2012

      Thanks, David! Had no idea you studied in Montreal. I agree,, the spirit is awesome!

  • May 26 2012

    Hells to the yes. I wish we stood up for things as much in America because my tuition was freakin $35,000 a year! It increased at least $1,000 every year. Where do schools think we get this kind of money?

    • June 03 2012

      I really hope Canada gets inspired from this change…

    • June 04 2012

      $35,000/YEAR?! SWEET MERCIFUL JESUS. That is astronomical!

  • May 27 2012
  • May 27 2012

    Excellent post, Candice, and beautifully musical film. Observing the protests from my strange and transitory perch here in Taipei I find myself thinking about time too, about time. Keep up the good work – we have traveled in a few similar global circles!

    • June 04 2012

      Thanks kindly, Joshua! I appreciate you reading.

  • May 27 2012

    Surprising(?) that I haven’t heard a word about this on BBC!

  • May 27 2012

    Thanks for this post. I don’t think everyone outside of Quebec really understands what this is about. Honestly I didn’t even know about Bill 78 until reading this post, which just shows I’ve been as ignorant as many others. The only media coverage of the protests I’ve seen seems to be of the more violent acts that have occurred, which gives the impression that Montreal is in some of chaos. The national media definitely seems to over-report on the more negative aspects, but I’m sure those instances aren’t as common as they appear.

    Quebec might have the lost tuition in Canada, but to have tuition increase by 75% over 5 years is staggering. As a current University student I know wouldn’t be able to afford 4 years of school if I had to pay 75% more in tuition than I am now. I commend these students for making a stand, because if they don’t, who will? If the line isn’t drawn here, then how far will things go? Canadians are granted many rights like freedom of speech and freedom of peaceful assembly, and it’s great to see that there are people actively using these rights.

    • June 04 2012

      “Quebec might have the lost tuition in Canada, but to have tuition increase by 75% over 5 years is staggering.” Exactly. Cheap tuition aside, that percentage of increase is unbelievable.

  • May 28 2012
    Susan

    Way to go! Thanks for this post. This IS important and in ways that reach beyond the price of tuition. Good God, Canada – do you SERIOUSLY not get the danger of this:
    “And then Bill 78 came along over a week ago, which “suspends the winter semester for striking students, and imposes strict limits on their protests, with restrictions guiding location, timing, and organization.”

    This is one of the basic freedoms of a democracy – the right to raise a collective voice in protest – no, not to harrass or commit arson or anything else – but the right to make your voice heard.

    I honestly am not a conspiracy-theorist or an alarmist in any way. Yeah, I tend to be complacent like a lot of people but I notice more and more instances of laws being written to curtail dissent and inconvenience, NOT to address injustices.

    Thanks again, Candice.

    • June 04 2012

      EXACTLY! Amen to dat. I don’t consider myself a revolutionary or an activist or anything of the sort, but it worries me that some people aren’t taking this seriously in the slightest.

      “This is one of the basic freedoms of a democracy – the right to raise a collective voice in protest – no, not to harrass or commit arson or anything else – but the right to make your voice heard.”

      Exactly.

  • May 31 2012
    Nancy

    Awesome post, Candice! Here is a link to a great article, mostly pointing out how the government is now trying pawn off debt, that an older generation is responsible for, onto the younger generation http://fullcomment.nationalpost.com/2012/05/24/john-moore-its-the-older-generation-thats-entitled-not-students/ .
    Also, I want to point out that most people try to prepare for the cost of their education BEFORE it happens, and now about a decade’s worth of students will be unprepared.
    This situation is so depressing; will politicians ever start doing what’s best for the country/provinces while also actually planning to help future generations?

    • June 04 2012

      Thanks lady! Most of the opposition I hear comes from the generation ahead of us, or those with high-paying jobs and zero student debt. I LOVE that NP article.

  • June 01 2012

    And this is why I love Montreal!

  • June 09 2012

    I’ve been following the news back in Canada. Though I don’t support people burning shit for fun (you always get a few of those), I’m glad to see people are hitting the streets to fight for their rights.

    • June 13 2012

      Ditto! There will always be a few assholes to make the bunch look bad, but for the most part, these people are great.

    • February 26 2013
      Jim

      I dont think 70$/yr over 5 years is a violation of anyones rights….Considering my tax dollars are subsidizing the current system…What about my rights as a tax payer?

    • February 26 2013
      Jim

      I dont think 70$/yr over 5 years is a violation of anyones rights….Considering my tax dollars are subsidizing the current system…What about my rights as a tax payer?

    • February 26 2013
      Jim

      I dont think 70$/yr over 5 years is a violation of anyones rights….Considering my tax dollars are subsidizing the current system…What about my rights as a tax payer?

    • February 26 2013
      Jim

      I dont think 70$/yr over 5 years is a violation of anyones rights….Considering my tax dollars are subsidizing the current system…What about my rights as a tax payer?

  • June 15 2012
    Cam

    Now imagine if the Montreal Canadians lost game 7 of the Stanley Cup finals! Oh wait, that’s just the Vancouverites… nevermind

    • June 18 2012

      Hahaha, apparently they riot here even if they win, so….

Leave a Comment

CommentLuv badge

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

FREE CANDIE FOR ALL!
SUBSCRIBE TO RECEIVE POSTS DIRECTLY TO YOUR INBOX